SARRAL found guilty of misusing musicians' royalties

Author: Eddie Hatitye
print email comment [ 27 ] share
 
 

Performance rights organization, The South African Recording Rights Association Limited (SARRAL), is to be wound up with immediate effect. According to the information we received, the ruling was issued at the Johannesburg High Court on Friday, 06 November 2009.

SARRAL had been fighting a long legal battle with renowned composer Colin Shapiro, who accused the organization of wrongfully appropriating royalty money in a bid to counter its financial problems.

SARRAL was factually insolvent many years ago and changed their accounting policy as a response to the liquidation action, according to investigations.

The judge ruled that SARRAL, as an agent had no right to use royalties as income and that it has to immediately close shop.

SARRAL's board and controllers conducted "systematic mismanagement" of the company and its accounting policy was in conflict with its constitutive documents, said the judge.

Investigations further revealed that SARRAL's financial statements from 2003 onwards mis-state the affairs of the company, treating musicians’ royalties as income.

However, a source from SARRAL, who requested to be anonymous, says while it is correct  that the judge ruled against  SARRAL , "nothing official has been issued telling SARRAL that it will be wound up"

 

 
comments
 
 
 
posted date: 16 Nov 09
Mr Shapiro: You took your concerns to the High Court in Jo\'burg, where your case and SARRAL\'s were judged on the objective facts alone in a fair and impartial setting. We all know that the Judge ruled in your and Galeta, your co-litigant\'s favour. The findings, ie the judgement from a Courtroom carries more weight and meaning than these hysterical, mean or malicious comments found in this forum. Such comments on this forum where there are no constraints about the substance of comments, is not surprising, and most likely originate from those who have been found wanting in respect of their conduct in running non-profit company which manages other people\'s money. SARRAL clearly plans to spend more of composers\' money in defending an indefensible unethical position, by trying to appeal the judges decision. I trust the law will take its proper course.
 
 
 
oznet
 
 
posted date: 15 Nov 09
Sarral has been appropriating composers and musicians royalties. I was commssioned in 2002 by SABC to write the music for their TV News programme \" Morning Live\" which now also includes\" Weekend Live\" The mechanical royalties generated for this music per year is quite substantial. I like so many other composers have not been correctly and adequately remunerated by Sarral. Because of this rogue and disgraceful behaviour by Sarral, I decided to become a co applicant with Colin Shapiro in his legal challenge against Sarral in court. The non payment of my royalties has caused great financial difficulties for me and my family. Thank God we have succeeded in our quest to close down this rip off rogue organization. By the way for those who play the race card and say Colin Shapiro is a racist, I am a proud South African black man who will champion your cause for accountability, equality and justice whether you are black or white !!! Aluta Continua ! Hotep Galeta
 
 
 
Hotep Galeta
 
 
posted date: 12 Nov 09
Thanks Su. A liquidator will be appointed soon to wind up SARRAL. All claims would have to be submitted to him. I will post news as it becomes available.
 
 
 
Colin Shapiro
 
 
posted date: 12 Nov 09
A long journey! Well done Colin!!! You hung in there when most of us gave up...... what does now happen to all our back claims???
 
 
 
Su
 
 
posted date: 11 Nov 09
malema: What happened is that SARRAL has been using over 50% of royalties to run the company. This was admitted in court by their advocate. Racism has nothing at all to do with this matter. Management past and present has abused over R36 million of royalty money. Let us stick to the facts.
 
 
 
Colin Shapiro
 
 
posted date: 11 Nov 09
when racist comments start appearing, you know that people have sunk to the lowest level.
 
 
 
tweak
 
 
posted date: 11 Nov 09
Ahhhhhh Mr shapiro what happend
 
 
 
malema
 
 
posted date: 11 Nov 09
DO YOU THINK SHAPIRO CARES ABOUT THE ARTISTS? SHAME ON YOU HE WAS THE ONE OF DIRECTOR DURING 1999-2004 WHEN SARRAL MD WAS WHITE WHY NOW STARTED EXPOSING THESE BECAUSE THE MD IS BLACK?
 
 
 
SIBONGILE
 
 
posted date: 11 Nov 09
a sad chapter. now we should look at SAMRO.
 
 
 
patrick
 
 
posted date: 11 Nov 09
I am lookin at the comment made by Colin Shapiro and I can't stop laughing @ the fact that he's got "Moshito Director" proudly written next to his name. I mean really?! Moshito in itself is a BIG joke! Talk about stealing money... hahaaaaaaaaaaaaaha! U guys crack me up...
 
 
 
Aphrodite
 
 
posted date: 11 Nov 09
I have to totally agree with Michaela\'s post. This issue and many others have been going on for far too long and if there is to be a grand architext or a body responsable for steering this thievery then let the perpetrators be known. Under the guise of assistance many an individual has been taken in and ill advised, this must stop. Let the evil do-ers make themselves known and purge themselves or let this be the beginning of their end.
 
 
 
Robin Kohl
 
 
posted date: 11 Nov 09
AT LONG LAST...... COLIN SHAPIRO\'S INTEGRITY AND COURAGE SHOULD BE PUBLICALLY ACKNOWLEDGED. IT\'S GIVEN ME FAITH IN THE SA JUDICIAL SYSTEM...AND FAITH IN SOUTH AFRICA
 
 
 
oznet
 
 
posted date: 11 Nov 09
re comment: I wonder what is next in this case Yes, since SARRAL can\'t tell the truth, how do we know waht is happening?!?!?!?
 
 
 
sifis
 
 
posted date: 10 Nov 09
busted!.... WHAT ABOUT OUR MONEY?
 
 
 
xtacy
 
 
posted date: 10 Nov 09
I wonder what is next in this case. Are we talking compesation or we lost from the Culprit(SARRAL). Do they close down with what is due to us?
 
 
 
Whizz Kid
 
 
posted date: 10 Nov 09
what about honest employees of SARRAL?
 
 
 
juju
 
 
posted date: 10 Nov 09
It\'s about damn time
 
 
 
Mr. Dime
 
 
posted date: 09 Nov 09
I suffered from this same instant too: I only received one year\'s worth of royalty money for doing the logo music for crimestop and missing/wanted which was broadcast every day on two SABC channels for years. if there is any more news or if i can do anything to contribute to this case please contact me at chien.pien@gmail.com
 
 
 
composer of crimestop music who also lost my royalty money
 
 
posted date: 09 Nov 09
negative comments about shapiro arise from lies spread by sarral themselves. only fools will believe these. great job shapiro the sa music industry is a better place now
 
 
 
tweak
 
 
posted date: 09 Nov 09
It is most interesting to note that one of Sarral\'s directors is Graeme Gilfillan.... who is outspokenly critical of other key players in the music industry. Perhaps he is always trying to deflect attention away from his/ Sarral\'s serious wrongdoings? Hmmmm...... It is easy to defame someone with lies... not so easy to do so in a courtroom for Judges make decisions based on facts not fiction.
 
 
 
Michaela
 
 
posted date: 09 Nov 09
This is makin me worry since I\'ve Just Registered My Publishing Company with SARRAL, Ive been in complete darkness about this. So were do we go from here? does everything continue as it is or do we stop everything?
 
 
 
El
 
 
posted date: 09 Nov 09
VERY VERY NICE. AT LAST WE GET SOME ACTION FROM THE HIGH COURT. MAY JUSTICE PREVAIL!!!!!!!!!!
 
 
 
rIAAN
 
 
posted date: 09 Nov 09
Congratulation to Shapiro! Let Justice prevail.
 
 
 
TrebleC
 
 
posted date: 09 Nov 09
Colin Shapiro is messed up old man who stole from SARRAL
 
 
 
malema
 
 
posted date: 09 Nov 09
SARRAL says: \"....nothing official has been issued telling SARRAL that it will be wound up\" What could be more official than a High Court Judgement?
 
 
 
Colin Shapiro
 
 
posted date: 09 Nov 09
Ironically this is only one case that same to the fore. Most artists put much trust in these institutions and have little or n means to verify the accuracy of reporting. This a shocking blow to an already struggeling local industry. Shame on the directors and management of Sarral. This an offence against the industry and public and should not be left here.
 
 
 
NameHdV
 
 
posted date: 09 Nov 09
thieves!!!
 
 
 
skilnet
 

 
submit comment

All comments must be approved by our editors, click here to read the editorial guidelines for comments. Please allow some time for our editors approve your comment after posting.
 
Required Fields
 
 
 
Please enter the text you see in the image below:

Verification Image


 
MIO Facebook Group Follow MIO on Twitter
 
>